“Stroke is a major cause of human disability and we are trying to come up with ways of giving people a larger dose of rehabilitation therapy, especially in the home, in order to reduce disability after stroke,” said Dr. Steven Cramer.
Cramer’s lab developed a home based tele-rehabilitation system that uses gaming to restore patient hand and arm function after stroke. Although rehabilitation therapy is commonly provided after stroke, many patients don’t get the benefits they need to truly regain function because of lack of access to therapy, high cost of therapy, and compliance. Cramer combined his medical knowledge with his earlier experience as a gamer growing up in the San Fernando Valley to create a gaming station that could help stroke patients practice movements and regain function.
The device, on which stroke patients can play games like “whack-a-mole” with a plastic mallet, was produced by a multidisciplinary team of rehabilitation, occupational, and physical therapists, as well as experts in neurology, gaming, motivational psychology, and computer programming.
Patients use the system under video conference supervision by clinicians at remote locations. “It provides a framework for exercises, for therapy, and also for education so that we can maximize prevention, to prevent the kinds of complications that can be anticipated after stroke such as another stroke, a heart attack, or depression,” said Cramer.
How game station rehab works
A patient is first evaluated for appropriateness for the program by a licensed therapist. The therapist enters examination results into a program which produces a customized 80-minute rehab session itinerary. The therapist can further adapt the program for the patient by dragging games or exercises onto the screen or modifying their difficulty or duration. The therapist then sends that treatment plan to the patient’s screen at home where the system, involving a computer and a wireless modem, have been delivered.
The patient has an agreed-upon daily start time with the therapist. During the hour prior to that, the system flashes and emits noises.
“It is all highly structured,” said Cramer. “The patient cannot use this as a computer. There is no keyboard. It is designed as an appliance.” Cramer emphasizes that patients don’t need any computer skills or literacy to use the system – they only need to be able to push a button. The therapist decides in each session which movements the patient needs to practice.
The movements are gamified. “If we want the patient to practice arm extensions, target arm movements, visually guided arm movements, reaching movements, we design the whack-a-mole game,” said Cramer, who proceeded to whack at buttons that lit up in succession with a plastic hammer, racking up points.
“I should point out one thing about the whack-a-mole game: most of the games take place like most video games on the screen,” said Cramer. “The person moves their hand to manipulate what happens on the screen. Whack-a-mole is one of our games that is in first person space. Unless you are an airline pilot, you don’t spend your day working in one visual space while looking at a different one. Instead, what most people do is look at and work in the same visual coordinate system. And that is what the whack-a-mole game does. Just because these are games, doesn’t mean there hasn’t been a lot of thought that goes into many of the details.”
The system provides the therapist with automated feedback. The therapist can see the patient’s score, a graph of scores over time, and a graph of successive scores over time according to the level of difficulty that was assigned. The therapist can then revise the settings in terms of duration or difficulty.
“The therapist can also talk to the patient and say, ‘I see your whack-a-mole score is getting better. How is your shoulder doing?’” said Cramer. “Or, ‘I see your scores have been going down. Have you been trying?’”
According to Cramer, patients need to have some minimal amount of language function to understand the directions. They also need to have sufficient communications skills to communicate if they are in distress, pain or have a problem. Other from that they just need to be able to follow the few basic instructions that appear on the screen.
The system has both supervised and unsupervised sessions.
During the unsupervised sessions, patients work through an 80-minute assignment including a 10-minute break. The system allows working intermittently so patients can take bathroom breaks or go shopping, for example. There is no interaction with the therapist, unless there is a problem. “We always have a mechanism to call in if there is an issue,” said Cramer.
A supervised day begins with a 30-minute video conference that is HIPAA-compliant. The patient will see the therapist’s face in the corner of the screen. The therapist can see the patient as well as the patient’s screen and activities. “In this way there is a live dialogue,” said Cramer. “You’ve got to have a human factor for this to have long term impact.”
Channeling the expertise of the therapist.
“Here we get into what makes a good therapist,” said Cramer. “It involves the human factor as well as understanding the medical science and the skill to implement it. We think we have retained all of these to some important degree in the design of this system.” The therapist has discretion in knowing what exercises to assign, and in how to best coach the patient and review progress through video conferences.
Cramer is conducting an NIH funded six week, 12-site clinical trial of the current telerehab-therapy program, dose and intensity-matched with traditional in-clinic rehabilitation, based on the encouraging results of a prior 28 day pilot study. The study, conducted through the new NIH clinical trials network for stroke, Strokenet consists of three supervised and three unsupervised sessions of 80 minutes duration per week. Each 80-minute session consists of games, exercises, education, some assessment modules and a 10-minute break in the middle. The patient does daily sessions 6 days a week.
Seventy nine patients are so far enrolled in the study, which is slated for 124 patients. “We hope to have an answer before the end of 2017 as to whether this tele rehab approach in the home is as good as what a therapist can do in the clinic,” said Cramer.
The study’s primary endpoint measures arm movement capacity that captures weakness, coordination, precision, timing, and strength, using the Fugl-Meyer Scale (so named after Axel Fugl-Meyer, the Norwegian rehab specialist). “The Fugl-Meyer Scale tells us how somebody’s arm is in terms of 0 being poorest to 66 being normal,” said Cramer.
A typical person entering the trial has a Fugl-Meyer score in the 20s, 30s, or 40s. In the pilot study of 12 patients who got 4 weeks of therapy, the average score increased by about 5 points. “To put that in context, scores of 5 points represent the minimal clinically important difference,” said Cramer. “That is to say, going up 5 points on the Fugl-Meyer Scale generally means that somebody’s arm has moved up one functional level — there’s something functional that they can do that they couldn't do before.” According to Cramer, in the pilot study half the subjects from just 4 weeks of daily rehab alone, using the prototype of this system in the home, improved by that minimal clinically important amount. “They exceeded the minimal clinically important difference,” said Cramer. “We will see how this newer system does in the current trial compared head to head with how traditional therapy does.”
Cramer’s team is writing grants to fund the next study to see the effects of larger rehab therapy doses for longer periods of time in more heterogeneous populations. “Possibly including going beyond stroke because a lot of the things we are doing here — in terms of better exercise, better activity, better function, better reserve, better cognitive activity, better education, mood screenings and so forth — is directly important to patients that have had a heart attack, patients who are healthy 75 year olds, patients who have renal failure, patients who have major depression,” said Cramer.
“In the longer term, what the dream is, I believe what we have here is an appliance that will be in the home of many patients for years,” said Cramer. “And that when somebody has an event, it will become useful in the internet of things to monitor their activity with various sensors to modulate their behavior using both computerized reflexes and actionable reports to medical professionals and to screen for known complications of what it is that was their index diagnosis.
I think this is just scratching the surface. We have to prove it step by step.”